People

Fall TV Blog

American Idol

Wednesday’s Idol: What You Didn’t See

March 13, 2008

PRE-SHOW FUN
Lucky fans that arrived early got to see the pre-show taping of a live performance from former Idol Katharine McPhee, who sang George Harrison’s “Something” accompanied by 14-time Grammy winner David Foster on the piano. The contestants looked a little stiff on the couches during the performance, as they were waiting to learn the results, but the judges enjoyed seeing a former runner-up doing so well. After her performance, Katharine (making sure that short skirt stayed down) made her way over to say hello to the hopefuls and then through the mosh pit to greet fans before finally stopping by Randy, Simon and Paula. The judges were ecstatic to see her, but even more excited to get a look at the ring on her finger and congratulate the recently married singer.

JIM HEARS AN IDOL
After the judges and Ryan Seacrest made their entrance one-by-one, hitting their marks and coming in perfectly on cue, the audience was wowed when a man in an elephant costume came into the crowd and turned out to be none other than Jim Carrey, dressed as Horton, from his new Fox film Horton Hears a Who! After sitting through the Beatles medley, which included “Can’t Buy Me Love” and “Help,” Carrey was escorted out of the stage area to change out of the big ears. He then watched the show with producer Nigel Lythgoe, and during one of the breaks, Randy and Simon came over to goof around with the funnyman.

WELCOME BACK, SANJAYA
Looking a little matured with his hair down and with goatee stubble, Sanjaya Malakar and his sister Shyamali were in the audience. Within moments of taking his seat, eager fans swarmed the former contestant to ask for autographs and photos. During the first break, Corey the warm-up guy alerted the crowd that Mr. Mohawk was in the house and asked, “Where’s the crying girl?” Later, the judges happily greeted last season’s teen sensation with hugs and kisses before posing for a photo.

DANNY & RAMIELE’S LOVE GOES ON
When Ramiele Malubay told PEOPLE that Danny Noriega is her other half and that “as long as I’m on this show, he has a ticket to be in my part of the audience,” she meant it, as the “Tainted Love” singer found himself sitting in the crowd for Wednesday’s results show. As fans came up to ask for autographs and photos, Danny obliged. Even Simon got up from his seat to chat with him during a break. But wearing a white T-shirt with a picture of Ramiele on the front and back that read “Vote for Ramiele,” his main focus was on his pal, as he blew kisses to her onstage.

THERE ARE SIGNS
There’s no shortage of David Archuleta support in the audience, as female fans go crazy with screams anytime his name is mentioned. One fan put it simply: “Imagine David Archuleta.” The same is true for Jason Castro, who definitely heard some squeals and probably saw some signs that read “I [heart] Jason” and “Sing to me, Jason.” David Cook and Michael Johns also got some Beatle-like screams of their own from women in the audience. One Chikezie fan, who couldn’t be there, had his friend relay a message by holding up a sign all night that read “Paul [hearts] Chikezie.” Paul, whoever and wherever you are, he got the message!

GOODBYE DAVID!
The goodbye for David Hernandez was an emotional one. The Idol stage was covered in tears as judges, contestants and even Ricky Minor came to bid him farewell. Chikezie, who has been roommates and a strong supporter of David since the beginning, let tears stream down his face as he watched his friend say goodbye. Simon took David aside and gave him a very long and endearing pep talk before Randy offered some words of wisdom. Syesha Mercado, who had been gripping hands with the other contestant in the bottom three, Kristy Lee Cook, only moments earlier, was also in tears as she said farewell. Then, all the contestants surrounded David in a heartfelt group hug to show their support and respect for the one America had dismissed. –Jed Dreben

Charley Gallay/WireImage

Permalink | Comments (78)

Comments + Add a comment

Leah March 13th, 2008

Kristy better keep crying, because she’s next to go!!!!

JULIA March 13th, 2008

America just let a great one go. That’s talent if u’ve never seen it.

Lauren March 13th, 2008

David did not do well Tuesday, but has a lot of talent and should have beat out Kristy and Syesha. Hopefully he will have a big singing career ahead. Too bad he won’t be on the tour.

sip March 13th, 2008

so glad we wont have to watch his weird dancing anymore.

Lizette L March 13th, 2008

I can’t believe Kristy is still around!!!David clearly should not have been the one to go!!

pol March 13th, 2008

i thought kristy will go…sign…

Randi March 13th, 2008

Whatever. Syesha has an amazing voice. Kristy should be the next one to go though.

Heather March 13th, 2008

If not this week, he would have went next week. But Kristy really needs to go. Syesha too, can’t be Miss Pefect forever.

I thought the big deal about the Top 12 was that they do get to go on tour. So if thats the case he’ll still be apart of that.

ruby March 13th, 2008

I think only the top 10 get to go on tour - I’m pretty sure it’s not all of the top 12. So whoever gets booted next, misses the train.

Kristy was bad. But David H was corny. It could have gone either way, but I would have prefered Kristy gone. We now have to endure another week of her butchering another song with her Dolly on helium voice.

Did you see the look on Syesha’s face when she was told she was in the bottom 3? Very humbling for somebody who thinks she’s all that. I’ll admit she’s pretty, but you need talent to win this competition.

Amy March 13th, 2008

they all have to go sometime he wasnt going to win no way i dont see why the order matters anymore. i want david cook to win

saffta March 13th, 2008

Lauren congratulations on your English. You had a perfectly well constructed comment.
Heather, on the other hand, should know that it is correctly stated as ’should have gone’, that’s requires an apostrophe as it is a contraction, and a part is two words in this context.
As for David Hernandez, I believe he’ll still be on the tour because the top 12 always are. He wasn’t going to win so it matters little whether you are first or 10th to go at this point.

ravenwoods March 13th, 2008

Sometimes it’s nice to read stuff like this and be reminded that the judges are a lot more human and compassionate than they appear on camera. I’m glad Sanjaya got such a warm welcome and it was great to see him there.

Jonathan Bodack March 13th, 2008

All the news on American Idol is very good, keep em coming! I’m Sorry David Herandez went, but that’s the whole point of the competition! Sanjaya looked different & not bad at all!

Shelly March 13th, 2008

I think Ramielle needs to go her preformance was stale and she keeps underpreforming week after week.

Colleen March 13th, 2008

There was too much with Jim Carrey last night…the results show could easily be a half hour instead of an hour. Kristy should have left this week, not David. She’ll be going next week for sure.

AJ March 13th, 2008

I think that David lost a lot of family votes because of his being a former stripper. He was a talented singer though!

Kammy March 13th, 2008

Syesha is fantastic. Some of you need to stop hating - she never claimed to be Miss Perfect. All she needs is to have that breakout performance because she is technically one of the best singers there.

Melita March 13th, 2008

I work with David’s mom and this just sucks. He was by far one of the most talented singers and to be let go after 1 not so great performance is crappy. I would feel that way even if I didn’t know his mom. Once again America got it wrong. Even if he wasn’t going to be the winner he should have at least stayed longer than some of the other sucky singers. This will be the last season I watch.

ruby March 13th, 2008

It’s true - only one person wins the competition and it doesn’t matter if you go first or 10th. Let the best singer win. Just enjoy the show for what it is.

Kammy, I don’t claim to “hate” Syesha. Like you said, she needs a breakout performance. If we haven’t seen one yet so how can I say she’s a great performer? She’s gotta be great every week and build that fan base. She can’t start building a fan base late in the game because she could get voted off before she has a chance. The same goes for Ramiele. Looked like a front runner early in the competition, but we haven’t seen a true breakout performance from her either. If she doesn’t have one soon, she’ll get voted off too.

Darrah March 13th, 2008

Kristy should definitely have been the one to leave. Her performance literally made me dizzy. I felt like I was in a fun house at a carnival with that music. It was absolutely horrible. Syeshia is amazing and she’s not going home. David wasn’t bad, I actually thought he was one of the better performers on Monday.

It doesn’t matter though I think David Cook and Carly Smithson are the best but David A. is gonna win.

Jem March 13th, 2008

Who is voting for Kristy? I mean, seriously!?!? David didn’t have a great night, but Kristy should have gone first. Syesha was alright, but forgettable. I was so bored during her performance.

JT March 13th, 2008

David Cook and Michael Johns ROCKS!

Julie March 13th, 2008

David H. was good, but he has nobody to blame but himself. When the news came out about his past, he basically hung himself. People want an “American Idol” that they can look up to with high standards. So even though you might hate to see him go, he did it to himself. Why anyone would try out for Idol with skeletons in their closet is beyond me, cuz they’re going to come out sooner or later. But I guess bad publicity is better than none at all.

Jade March 13th, 2008

Please send Ryan Seacrest home…..

JT March 13th, 2008

David Cook and Michael Johns Rocks

HKV March 13th, 2008

I agree JT, they are the best two!!

ruby March 13th, 2008

LOL .. good one Jade!!

Nancy-Miami-FL March 13th, 2008

my opinion Mercado and Cook
had to go before David
i think FOX PEOPLE had something
to do with his departure to avoid
any more talk about David’s past
which shouldnt even be an issue
HIS VOICE was GOOOOOD

Tammy March 13th, 2008

I agreed with the bottom three, however, I felt David was the best of those three. Kristy sucked! Please tell me she’s not going to hold on for several weeks and annoy me like Haley Scarnato did last year.

Peggy March 13th, 2008

There is something wrong with a fan base who lets Sanjaya stay for a long time and cuts a handsome, talented guy like David Hernandez.

Sabrina March 13th, 2008

If I see another picture of Sanjaya I’m going to have nightmares.

vegas March 13th, 2008

kristy should have gone home - she was horrible, just horrible…david should of had at least one more shot

Sarah March 13th, 2008

Kristy should’ve gone for sure. I was suprised they let her sing her super ho-down remix again!!

Ada March 13th, 2008

It is nice to hear that all the judges, Simon especially were talking to David H. after the show, giving him advice, encouragement.

Trasur March 13th, 2008

Wrong choice America. David H. has got such a great voice and he’s versatile with his signing. WHY IS AMANDA STILL THERE???????????????????. She can only sing rock and nothing else. Her voice is horrible to listen to.

Kim March 13th, 2008

Kristy or Syesha need to go next

roxanne March 13th, 2008

I LOVE Ryan Seacrest!

Kirby March 13th, 2008

Do you know where I can find the leopard print dress that Carly Smithson wore on the results show for American Idol on Wednesday, March 12th.

Ellie March 13th, 2008

Ryan & Simon make the show what it is. The comments that have been made about them and some of these individuals performing is just plain ugly. Put yourself in their shoes. Cut people some slack.

Lainie March 13th, 2008

Why do they make us suffer through the three worse performances AGAIN!!

Deivid March 13th, 2008

i think that sanya its really gay, im gay but iam not look than so gay just like him. he´s really discusting and scary. HE SUCKSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

Deivid March 13th, 2008

HE SUCKSSS

matilda_candy March 13th, 2008

I didn’t like David in the first place, but Kristy should have gone. The only song she can sing is Amazing Grace.

Love y’all,

matilda_candy

Taylor March 13th, 2008

Okay, David Hernandez was soooooo hot!!! Like, there was no reason for him to have left. (And that’s besides the fact that he was hot) Is it true that he was an exotic dancer originally? Either way–HOTTIE!!♥

JuiceyJ March 13th, 2008

Amazing Grace is the ONLY song Kristy can sing… she shoulda been gone long ago!!!!

melissa March 13th, 2008

The Amanda chick looks like Cruella De Vil.

K March 13th, 2008

Just to let the one poster no, corny and bad are two different things. David may have been corny, but he had a great voice and deserved to stay in the competition. To think he got voted off before Kristy and Amanda. Don’t get me wrong, I love Amanda, but a lot of people have been gunning for her, but I’m glad she’s still in the competition. Kristy should have been the one to go. Everything about her performances has been BAD. Listen to her vocals, they’re BAD. She’s only in the competition, because she tries to use her looks as an advantage. What made me hate her even more last night was the fact that she made the comment that she didn’t think she deserved to be in the bottom 3 last night, or she said something along those lines. I can’t stand her or her singing.

RC March 13th, 2008

Amanda sucksssssssssss. Get her off. Maybe if she goes it will be a better show.

kristie March 13th, 2008

all the idols are good. it is just a matter of who is better. go arch and d cook

niko March 13th, 2008

my money is on jason (love, love, LOVE the dreads!), david cook, the Irish girl with the sleeve art and brooke. everyone else needs to say , “ciao!”

Nikki March 13th, 2008

“Julie” please save it. Dig into anyone’s past and there’s bound to be skeletons in their closet. No one claims to be perfect. I may not agree with David at one time being a stripper, but there is a lot worse out there. It’s none of my business as much as it isn’t anyone else’s. Athletes, actors, singers….have at least done something in their past they may not be proud of. Many Idol contestants have DUI’s from their past, but are you going to demand they be off the show? They were driving over the legal limit to be charged….so are you going to say its okay to drive drunk and possibly kill people and put people’s lives at risk? There is no right and there is no wrong. It is what it is. Certainly David being a stripper doesn’t define the person he is. He did something that someone like myself doesn’t agree with, but that surely doesn’t make him a bad person. I don’t judge a book by its cover. This is “American Idol,” a singing/talent competition, and nothing more than that. As long as someone like David isn’t a child molester, rapist or murderer, it doesn’t bother me what he chose to do in life.

Lisa March 13th, 2008

I can’t stand the medley of songs performance that all of the idols have to do when the show starts. It is always so bad and uncomfortable to watch. I like Brooke, she is one of my favorites but she looks very awkward when she is dancing around.

Kelly March 13th, 2008

Maybe it’s just me, but I think D.H.’s departure has much more to do with his supposed sexual orientation than with his ability to sing. I knew that after the “gay bar” scandal Dave would be the first to go. Is it truly possible that America thought Kristi’s performance was better? No way! I don’t even think America voted that way. Rather, I think the producers are either homophobic, or worried about loosing viewers and just simply ignored the votes this week!

Harper March 13th, 2008

I agree Cruella De Vil must go!!!!

Kaitlyn March 13th, 2008

I heard David H. used to work in a gay bar. People say he had the body that guys liked. Kristy should have gone home! She was really bad. She is defenialty the next one to go!

maw March 13th, 2008

i agree with you trasur, for sure

Annie March 13th, 2008

I wasnt mad that david got off i never really liked him a lot but i didnt hate him. Kristy shouldve gone though, she shouldnt have even made the top 12.

Tina March 13th, 2008

I think Kristy is good and hope she is not next to go. You guys are mean. She is also very attractive and will go places. Although cute, sweet and nice voice, I think Ramielle should go next. David Cook will probably win this competition- he is awesome.

tracy March 13th, 2008

Katherine.. why would you turn a song that was sung to you at your wedding by your husband, and try to make a hit out of it? I think you just ruined the “Moment”. Sorry David, I thought you would have come out at the top 5.

cristina March 13th, 2008

EXACTLY!!!! KRISTY HAS GOT TO GO!!! I WAS SO SAD TO SEE DAVID LEAVE. HE HAS AMAZING TALENT!

T0NGAN kWEEN March 13th, 2008

HE WUSNT DAT GEWd..i AiNT TRY’N TA HATE..TRUTH HURTz..!!

Ika Pratignyo March 13th, 2008

I cant believe Kristy is staying! C’mon, America, wake up!

deb rab March 13th, 2008

david h. i hope you read this. You rock! When you sang “rolling stone” i replayed it - something that I almost have never done. I’m sure you were voted off not because of your voice but because of your “checkered” past. However, this is not a contest of morality, but a singing competition. You seem like you could be a “great” and I mean “great” all around performer. I think influential people saw you perform and I feel that you have a great career ahead of you. Just make sure “rolling stone” is on your first album.

md March 13th, 2008

What is up… Why is that screaming freak, skunk looking broad still on Idol. There was only one Janice and that’s all there will ever be. I thought this was a singing compitition??? Sorry that girl cannot sing!

Rae March 14th, 2008

Would have like to have seen Ramiele go - she is BORING!

Stuart March 14th, 2008

love to hear ramiele hit her big voice! I think she’s the underdog in this competition..

Amy March 14th, 2008

David was geeky…he had no looks…and lets face it…he wasn’t going to be anyones idol. Kristy is a better choice…she could sell more records than him…he will be forgotten within a week!

Desiree March 14th, 2008

America screwed up!!! I was SHOCKED when I heard it was David and not Kristy. David has a great voice, and should not have been dismissed. We’ll see him again, I’m sure! Kristy needs to change her singing style or she’s next to go…should have been her this time!

Shintya March 14th, 2008

The only one who doesn’t deserve to be on the top 12 is Kristy. They better swap her for Asia’h Epperson or Danny Noriega. At least, Danny would bring some fun to the show. Sorry to Kristy fans.

kl March 14th, 2008

Krissy is going next,then Ramiele will be going.

elainer7 March 14th, 2008

Sanjaya has had his 15 minutes of fame. Its time for him to disappear.

Jill March 14th, 2008

Saffta,

If you’re going to start critiquing every poster’s grammar you’ll never leave your computer. But, it’s half the fun of reading these posts!

BTW, Heather was referring to the future so I believe “would have” was correct, not “should have”.

ruby March 14th, 2008

I think we no the difference between bad and corny. If you like corny, you should have voted for him.

If Kristy actually believed she didn’t deserve to be in the bottom 3, then I wanna know what she’s been inhaling. Pass the reefer.

Courtney March 14th, 2008

Honestly, I’m mad David Hernandez left. He was a very good singer. Kristy Lee Hook(er) should have left way before him. All she can sing is country. Amanda needs to go home too. I like her style but her singing is horrible. David A. is deffinatly going to win, either him or Brooke White!!!!!!

pinkyyy March 15th, 2008

i definitely agree with courtney i am sure david archuleta will win american idol easy…………he is talented, smart,cute,down-to-earth,likable (as SIMON said) and great vocalist.
He is ma favourite and so is america’s……..

pinkyyy March 15th, 2008

and i hate DAvid COOk
He better get voted off or he is gone!!!!

Lorraine March 16th, 2008

Why doesn’t Simon ask Amanda if she could do anything other than “rock” like he’s asked contestants in the past. Let’s see what else she’s capable of singing. I’d bet NOTHING ELSE!! She’s terrible at ROCK and not even worse at other vocals!!! That’s my bet!!!! Come on Simon, tell her!!!!!! What are you waitinf or?????????

bosco March 17th, 2008

I thought this country was better than that. David H should not have been eliminated. Kristy Lee Cook should have been. She was by far the worst of the bunch. This country is still so closed minded. Wake up people … live and let live. David H was headed for the the top 5, and we all know it. Too bad people are so prejudiced. Judge not lest ye be judged.

Advertisement

Add a Comment




Powered By WordPress

Photos and More

Meet Dancing's New Contestants!

An Emmy winner, a Grammy winner and two Olympians - get to know the cast of season 7 before they hit the dancefloor

Project Runway: 14 Looks We Love

But do you agree? Vote on season 5's most inspiring outfits

Advertisement

The Shows

  • 90210
  • American Idol
  • America's Next Top Model
  • The Bachelor
  • The Bachelorette
  • Dancing with the Stars
  • Desperate Housewives
  • Grey's Anatomy/Private Practice
  • Gossip Girl
  • The Hills
  • Project Runway
  • So You Think You Can Dance
  • Top Chef

Don't Miss

Watch the First 5 Minutes of Gossip Girl's Season 2 Premiere

More on People.com

Simon on New Idol Judge: We Had a Pajama Party!

"It's already a big happy family," Paula Abdul added Tuesday at the auditions in New York

Heidi Montag's '80s Aerobics Video Debuts

Decked out in a leotard and legwarmers, The Hills star works out to "Overdosin'"

Shannen on Her Reunion with Jennie

"I never even gave any thought to it being awkward," she reveals of working with her former costar

VIDEO: Kim Kardashian Shows Off Dancing Moves

The DWTS contestant tries to hide her "clumsiness" and demonstrates a spot turn