People

Fall TV Blog

American Idol

Wednesday’s Idol: What You Didn’t See

March 20, 2008

All Growed Up: Hello, Kellie Pickler!
At the pre-show taping of season five favorite Kellie Pickler’s performance of “Red High Heels,” Ryan Seacrest jokingly reminded everyone just how much she has “grown in so many ways since leaving us.” receiving a bit of a chuckle from those in the audience who caught the double entendre. The former Idol came out to cheers in her conservative red dress — a contrast from her signature low-cut tops — and had the Idols, especially country crooner Kristy Lee Cook, rocking away! After giving a little wave to Chicken Little (season five’s Kevin Covais), the highest-wattage of celebrity in the audience, Pickler strutted over to sing flirtatiously to judge Simon Cowell. Once she gave him a little sashay goodbye, she then moved on to an eager Randy Jackson and gave a hello wave to in-house music director Ricky Minor, tapping his bass up above.

The crowd loved the performance and got out of their seats to show it. Afterward Pickler humbly greeted fans in the pit, saying, “How are ya?” before shaking hands and waving goodbye. Later, still in her red dress, Pickler hung out off to the side with producer Nigel Lythgoe, watching the show on the monitor and discussing the recap of the previous night’s performances.

What About Randy?
During the Q&A session, one fan asked Simon and Paula Abdul if they would do a sequel to their famous kissing scene. Without letting Paula even blink, Simon quickly said, “My answer is yes. Why?” He then turned to Paula to tell her, “You’re actually a very good kisser.”

Is That You, Simon?
Simon must have been drinking happy juice out of that ever-present Coca-Cola cup, because from the minute the usually acerbic judge walked in and took his seat, he was nothing but smiles. Rather than do his usual entrance around the pit, this night he went right through his fans, shaking hands, throwing high fives and doling out hellos.

Ryan’s Back, Paula Go Back!
Whoever was standing in as the calmer Ryan the night before has definitely been replaced — the wacky host was back to his old tricks. During the pre-taped Q&A, Ryan was already having at Simon, bashing his $1 million automobile purchase and even blaming him for screwing up the first take. Meanwhile Paula had a typical wacky moment of her own. After telling fans earlier that she was suffering from a “little laryngitis,” she made her way to her chair only to realize she was alone! Randy and Simon were still backstage while airtime was spent on pre-taped segments. But Paula just shrugged off the gaffe, laughing before joining her fellow judges, who were relaxing backstage.

Carly’s Teary Break
When Ryan announced that strong-voiced Carly Smithson was in the bottom three, a lot of jaws dropped in shock. Hearing the news, tears began to stream down Smithson’s face. During the break, a sympathetic Seacrest made his way over to hug and comfort her, along with Debbie the stage manager. Then David Archuleta, Brooke White and Nigel Lythgoe went over to see if they could cheer her up. Finally the fans got into it, yelling out words of encouragement to the Idol and succeeded — she smiled!

Johns’ Mom in the House
During one of the breaks, Corey the warm-up guy asked Michael Johns just whom he was waving to so much in the audience. Johns quickly answered, “My mom’s here from Australia!” And so were his dad and sister, too. The family stood up and waved to their Idol, who had just learned that he was in the Top 10. Knowing that Mom was in the house might have put Johns on his most gentlemanly behavior: In his family’s sight, he offered his hand to the Idol ladies as they made their way up to the second level of the couch.

Amanda’s Big Goodbye
Carly was still all tears, dabbing a tissue to her eyes, when big-voiced Amanda Overmyer received her walking papers (rather than Kristy Lee Cook). After Amanda finished one last performance of the Beatles’ “Back in the USSR,” the Top 10 swarmed her with tearful hugs. But before the judges could offer their goodbyes, a cool-headed Amanda was already doing an exit interview with the Idol Extra TV crew. Still, Paula wrapped her arms around the young Idol and squeezed tight as she offered final words-and then Paula made her way to Chikezie to give him a giant congratulatory bear hug for surviving the cut. –Jed Dreben

Fame

Permalink | Comments (184)

Comments + Add a comment

Pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | … 19 | Next | Show All

Jennifer March 20th, 2008

I think it was totally messed up that Carly was in the bottom 3!! I was ready to boycott Idol if she got sent home. America is voting for the wrong people!! Carly is the best singer there!! Kristy sucks and needs to be sent home!! Don’t waste your votes on Kristy! Vote for Carly!!!!

Stacy March 20th, 2008

Carly had her chance already.

mo March 20th, 2008

I cannot believe Kristy made it yet again. She is totally off key, flat and boring. I agree with Simon 100% that she is not a performer. Amanda at least knows how to get the crowd into it, and for her genre of music, did so much better than Kristy. This again confirms to me that this contest is not about the best singer, and that is too bad as in the end, if the winner is not the best of this top 10, then what are we left with? You do the math on how many of the #1 winners have made it, and then we have those who dropped out at say 4 and 7 who are making it big time. Sorry Amanda, the wrong one was eliminated. You would have rocked the house in the top ten tour.

kstar March 20th, 2008

I am sooo glad that Amanda is finally gone! I couldn’t stand to watch her, raspy yelling voice another week. Next week Kristy… then Jason Castro. Does he not give anyone else the creeps? He has an okay voice, but completely lacks the ability to perform. My final vote is for David Cook, Michael Johns and Carley. I think Brooke is the dark horse that my climb to the top and surprise us all.

Jenn March 20th, 2008

I do not like Carly! This is American Idol, and I can’t see someone with an irish accent winning! Plus she had her chance! Other people haven’t been so lucky and that should be what idols about. VOTE CARLY OUT AMERICA!!!

zona March 20th, 2008

Carly’s tatoos are a turn off!

Kalena March 20th, 2008

I’m still in shock that Carly made bottom 3. I don’t think Amanda would have won AI, but she brought something different to the show. Kristy is boring and I cannot believe is still hanging in there. Does this remind you of Sanjaya? =) Carly rocks!

Michi March 20th, 2008

Jenn–what does Carly’s Irish accent have to do with anything? Michael Johns has an Australian accent. Stop being ignorant, it’s a singing competition.

Stay-at-Home-Mom March 20th, 2008

Soooooo happy Amanda was sent packing and won’t be joining the AI tour….Wouldn’t pay to see her sing but then again, she can’t sign…Duh!!!Ugh, she’s terrible…Now, let’s move on…

Brooke March 20th, 2008

Kristy doesn’t suck…. Amanda needed to go home. She wouldn’t do well with versatility in the real world. Carly should not have been in the bottom 3, I agree. Kristy has the country-vibe… and is wholesome and girl-next-door in her appearance. I like her.. She’s not my favorite.. Brooke White is… but stop saying anyone sucks.

Pages: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | … 19 | Next | Show All

Advertisement

Add a Comment




Powered By WordPress

Photos and More

Dancing: Celebrate Brooke Burke's Victory!

Our man Griffin salutes the hot mama and recaps the sexiest, scariest and silliest moments of the past season

BFF Alert: Real Housewives Vicki & NeNe Visit N.Y.C.!

The ladies of Orange County and Atlanta dish about meeting New York's Bethenny

Advertisement

The Shows

  • 90210
  • American Idol
  • America's Next Top Model
  • The Bachelor
  • The Bachelorette
  • Dancing with the Stars
  • Desperate Housewives
  • Grey's Anatomy/Private Practice
  • Gossip Girl
  • The Hills
  • Project Runway
  • So You Think You Can Dance
  • Top Chef

Don't Miss

Chris Harrison: You Could Be the Next Bachelorette

Host Chris Harrison and producers are searching for women "from any walk of life" to look for love on the show

More on People.com

The Hills Recap: Heidi Gets the Ax

Plus: Audrina moves out on a surprised LC

Desperate Housewives Recap: Make Ups, Breakups and a New Romance?

Susan reconciles with Jackson, Lynette leaves Tom and Katherine gets neighborly with Mike

The Bachelorette's DeAnna Pappas Splits with Jesse Csincsak

"It's our responsibility to tell you we're not together anymore," Csincsak says in an online video

Brooke & Derek's Perfect Night

The couple reclaim the top spot with a stunning foxtrot. Plus: Len returns - cranky as ever